Skip to content

If you loved Penpal

Books like Penpal

If you loved Penpal by Dathan Auerbach, these are the books its readers love most, closest first: chosen from the ratings and recommendations of the readers who loved it.

No. 1

It

Stephen King

No. 2

Coraline

Neil Gaiman

No. 3

Rosemary's Baby

Ira Levin

No. 4

Let the Right One In

John Ajvide Lindqvist

No. 5

The Turn of the Screw

Henry James

No. 6

Night Film

Marisha Pessl

No. 7

Ghost Story

Peter Straub

No. 8

Hell House

Richard Matheson

No. 9

At the Mountains of Madness

H P Lovecraft

No. 10

Carrion Comfort: A Novel

Dan Simmons

No. 11

Come Closer

Sara Gran

No. 12

Gothic Tales

Elizabeth Cleghorn Gaskell

No. 13

Heart-Shaped Box: A Novel

Joe Hill

No. 14

Horrorstor: A Novel

Grady Hendrix

No. 15

Interview with the Vampire by Anne Rice (Book Analysis): Detailed Summary, Analysis and Reading Guide (BrightSummaries.com)

Bright Summaries

No. 16

Pet Sematary: A Novel

Stephen King

No. 17

Ring (Ring Trilogy)

Koji Suzuki

No. 18

Something Wicked This Way Comes: A Novel

Ray Bradbury

No. 19

The Case Against Satan

Ray Russell

No. 20

The Frangipani Hotel

Violet Kupersmith

No. 21

The Hunger

Alma Katsu

No. 22

The Ruins

Scott Smith

No. 23

The Silence of the Lambs

Thomas Harris

No. 24

The Silent Companions: A Novel

Laura Purcell